Business Sues Yelp Reviewer – And Wins Revised Review!
Did you hear about the contractor who sued the woman who left him a bad Yelp review?
Yikes! It’s getting messy out there with defamation claims coming up against free speech rights. And the courts are starting to weigh in. More on that below.
But first, what does all this mean for small and local businesses who are affected by online reviews?
How (and should) a local small business deal with negative or unfair reviews?
Should you just ignore all online reviews and let people talk? Does it ever make sense to respond to a negative review online?
Did you know there are ethical and legitimate ways to increase your amount of good reviews and even turn bad situations into positive reviews? We detail all the options here…
Local Small Business Implications For Review Sites
Local review sites like Yelp can be a boon, a bane or just part of the background of doing business in today’s online world.
Pages of glowing reviews can drive new customers excitedly in the door, but as the contractor who sued knows, too many bad reviews, or even one harsh accusatory one, can do serious damage.
Options To Deal with Bad Reviews Online
Suing a reviewer is obviously an extreme reaction. Here are some other options for dealing with online reviews:
Don’t Respond At All – Many business choose to just let all their online reviews stand. This isn’t a terrible approach because even responding to bad reviews can be tricky business. Even in the days before the internet – people talk, what are you gonna do? But even if you decide not to respond, at least do the following…
At Least Read Your Reviews – It’s easy to recall what you’re doing well and dismiss bad reviewers as a couple of “Negative Nelsons”. But too many negative online reviews can hurt your sales so it’s better to hear the bad news. It may turn out there are indeed issues of which you’ve been unaware. Once addressed, the bad reviews will fade into the past and be replaced with positive reviews. And if the reviewers note the positive changes (we’ve seen this a lot), previous and future customers can be assured the problems of the past have been corrected.
Answering Your Critics – If you do decide to reply to a negative review on the review site, it’s important not to blame or insult the customer. Don’t come across as defensive or sarcastic and don’t get dragged into hashing out online the details of their experience. Reviews are mostly read by customers and potential customers so they’re more likely to side with your disgruntled guest if it feels like an argument is taking place.
How To Address Negative Reviews Diplomatically – Never get into an argument or use sarcasm. State that you are truly sorry the customer had a bad experience, state that you take their concerns seriously, emphasize your commitment to quality and let everyone know that you or your staff are available and trained to address problems right away because your goal is to be sure everyone leaves a satisfied customer. This will make it easier for readers to empathize with a caring business owner and serve soften the impact of the negative review.
Of course this only works if there are only a few negative reviews. See our next step to learn how to build up a bank of good reviews to protect your average against the occasional complaint.
Ask For Reviews Proactively (More Below) – It’s better to build up a base of good reviews than to be caught off guard by excessive bad reviews later. Also, the fewer reviews you have in general, the more the bad ones will stick out. So stack the deck with good ones by encouraging the quiet, happy customers to speak up.
Turn Mistakes Into A Customer’s Feel-Good Story – Mistakes are going to happen, but when you’ve created an environment in which your staff knows that an unsatisfied customer experience is unacceptable, correcting mistakes can be a major opportunity.
A bad situation that gets correct creates a perfect little mini-drama. As long as the story has a happy ending, their journey from initial high hopes, to problem, to happy resolution creates the perfect anecdote for your customers to share online and with their friends.
As long as there is a hero you provide in the form of an attentive staff member who does what it takes to fix the situation, someone’s initial displeasure can be turned into a cute story to share. People love these types of vignettes with a happy ending.
How to Ask For Reviews
Email Follow Up
The best way to get a review is to directly ask for them. How? Getting a customer’s email address is often the preferred way to communicate because once you have a customer’s email address you can keep in touch with them. There are many legitimate reasons to ask for an email address (to confirm appointments, to send future sales and coupons, in order to access your literature on your website, etc).
Once you have their email it’s very easy and efficient to create a series of automatic emails to go out. A service like AWeber is only $19 a month for your first 500 subscribers and offers simple step-by-step guidance that teaches novice email marketers to set up an automated series. This is the best way to be sure emails go out without requiring a staff member to manage each customer correspondence.
Broadcast emails like sales, events, announcements, newsletters, and blog posts can be easily sent to your list once you have this type of system in place. These are great tools to build relationships and even gain a few extra sales.
In Store Signage
When collecting their email is not feasible, like at a restaurant for example, consider location signage asking for reviews. With the prevalence of smart phones and tablet computers it’s never hurts to place reminders in locations where people are waiting and likely to pull out their device. On a table tent or on the check at a restaurant, etc.
FYI – We’ve frequently noticed signs asking for reviews in dentist and doctors’ offices. And we’re talking about high-end providers. If the practice sounds cheesy, rest assured it’s being done tastefully in better establishments from Back Bay Boston to Manhattan Beach, CA.
Regardless of how you communicate with your customers, be sure to encourage them to notify you immediately of any issues not to their satisfaction. An important part of this is to train your staff to be sure they know how important it is that all guests/patients etc. are happy. Again, the way to know is to ask. Once a patron seems satisfied asking for a review might be appropriate, or rely on the signage or followup email depending on your service model.
Show Up In More Than Just Review Sites
It’s best if when people search your business by name that you appear in multiple local listing sites and not just in the review sites. This will ensure that anyone looking for things like your location, specials or operating hours can find you easily without automatically being drawn into reading reviews.
It might be tempting to let the review sites do the local listing work for you, but it’s not a safe strategy for searchers to only find you there.
A better method is to get your name, address, website and phone number to appear in many local listing sites such as possible such as YellowPages, WhitePages, CitySearch, Foursquare, Google Maps and more. This way you can have control and offer many more places for people to find you outside of review sites.
Rather than update your information site-by-site you can use a service that puts you on all the sties and databases the serve the local search results for less than $150 a year (see below). Being listed with more sites gives you many more placement opportunities to get found the local search results and maps listings.
These services also list you in GPS services like Garmin and TeleNav and in iPhone, Android and Blackberry 411 directory assistance databases.
Example – How big of an opportunity is local search? Recently we were searching for “tacos” in Torrance, CA in the Google Maps app of our Android phone – and there we no listings within about 10 miles! Yet there were dozens of taco places within two miles of our location. The first one that gets listed will be the only business to show up on the map.
If there are opportunities to list Tacos near L.A., you can be sure there are many other opportunities out there.
Other Amusing Ways To Deal with Bad Online Reviews
There’s a good article on these topics and more in Web Pro News. We like this anecdote from their article,
“Some businesses, rather than suing or paying for good reviews, are simply having fun with the bad ones. I prefer this approach. San Diego’s Craft & Commerce is recording their bad Yelp reviews, and playing them for customers while they’re in the bathroom. Seriously. Awesome idea.”
We agree it’s an awesome approach. It reminds us of another business owner who put quotes from his bad Yelp reviews on his staff T-shirts that we wrote about last year (photo at top). This shows you can take the heat and demonstrates your personality.
Online Business Review Notes and News
Media Stories Are Not Reality
It’s important to remember that the media specializes in, “Man Bites Dog” stories, not dog bites man. In other words, the stories that get reported are out there because they’re exciting to read. And they’re exciting to read because they are unusual.
It’s rare that bad reviews lead to catastrophic consequences and court cases. We hope to provide food for thought but we hope you don’t need to feel the need to prepare for battle.
Yelp Has To Deal With Google SEO Too!
Welcome to our world, Yelp. Yelp is accusing Google of unfairly putting Google’s reviews before Yelp’s reviews in the search results.
Is Google unfairly gaming their “organic” search results, or wisely watching out for their own best interests? Why can’t Google use their own popular platform they invested in and built? What if Google reviews are as valid as Yelp’s? What is fair to the searcher? The mechanics of Google’s algorithm is top secret so we don’t know if the results are in fact “gamed” or truly served up organically based on the algo!
But what this does show is that even big companies like Yelp have to contend with Google placement issues.
Yelp Sued for “Best Of” Use
And online reviews are causing turmoil in the offline world – Yelp is being sued by Village Voice Media Holdings, publishers of the Voice and alternative weeklies in other cities, which claims they own the “Best Of [A City]” concept and therefore Yelp is infringing on their trademark when Yelp uses the term on the Yelp site. It appears Yelp is taking readers from these published and these weeklies are also using the courts to fight back.
Contractor Sues Yelp Reviewer
The basics of this story are, a former customer accused a contractor not just of doing a bad job, but of stealing jewelery from her home. The contractor felt the negative review was costing them business and a judge made the reviewer change her review. You can read all the details here in the Washington Post.
Conclusion – Take Steps To Control Reviews And Local Search Results
Online reviews are local listings are now a well-established part of local internet marketing. There no reason to be at the mercy of review sites and reviewers when you can take positive and proactive solutions.
The first is to position yourself all over the search results pages and in the map listings for your neighborhood. The second step is it to ensure a large volume of good review by regularly asking your happy customers to submit reviews.